bcg blog

Releasing Reputation

Throughout her career, Serena Williams faced a common challenge that most athletes experience, but to an extreme degree. For her, the scrutiny was constant not just of her performance, but of her body, her emotions, her fashion, and her authenticity. For years, she could have shaped herself to fit others' expectations, softened her intensity to seem more acceptable, or hidden her emotions to protect her reputation.
Serena made a different choice. She faced resistance from traditionalists within the tennis community because of her outspoken nature, but rather than retreat, she leaned into authenticity. While fans saw her as a strong and utterly powerful person who never gives up, privately she knew otherwise. Serena once explained how her on-court self is completely different from her off-court personality. When she opened up about her struggle with confidence, the vulnerability - showing both her strength and her fragility - could have damaged her carefully cultivated image as an invincible competitor.
Then she let go. Serena stopped trying to manage everyone's opinion of her. She had become a mother and vulnerability flowed. She was now mild-mannered and acknowledged that her body was different. Her devotion had shifted from focusing solely on tennis to raising her daughter. Serena began releasing her grip on her reputation and embracing her full self - the fierce competitor, the devoted mother, the outspoken advocate. 
Needless to say, she didn't lose influence. She gained it. 
Why Should We Care?
Here’s a truth of leadership: the energy you spend managing your reputation is energy you can't invest in actual growth and impact. Most people live in a prison of reputation management, carefully curating their image, avoiding vulnerability, and making decisions based on how they'll be perceived rather than what's genuinely right or necessary. This creates an exhausting dilemma where excellence requires authenticity and boldness, but protecting reputation demands conformity and caution. The leaders who break through to transformational impact are those who realize that releasing concern for reputation isn't reckless - it's the only way to access their full capacity for leadership.
Leaders worried about their reputation make conservative choices designed to avoid criticism rather than choices designed to create value. They delay difficult conversations to preserve likability, withhold controversial opinions to maintain consensus, and pursue visible achievements that look impressive rather than meaningful work that might go unnoticed. But leaders who have released their attachment to reputation can take the risks that excellence requires. They can admit mistakes without fearing professional death, champion unpopular ideas without needing immediate validation, and prioritize long-term impact over short-term approval.
High achievers who remain bound by reputation concerns often find themselves performing a version of success rather than experiencing excellence - achieving goals that impress others while neglecting pursuits that fulfill them, maintaining an image of having it all together while struggling privately, and measuring worth by external validation rather than internal alignment. When you stop trying to protect your reputation, you often build a better one - because authenticity and courage are ultimately more compelling than carefully managed perfection.
REAL TALK - Action Steps
Releasing your reputation doesn't mean abandoning professionalism or character - it means freeing yourself from the exhausting work of impression management so you can focus on meaningful contribution. Here’s a few ideas on staying on that path:

• Take Inventory 
  
  • Write down three specific things you're afraid people might think or say about you if you were completely authentic. Be honest. Now, deliberately do one small thing this week that risks triggering that reputation concern. Notice what actually happens versus what you feared would happen. Most reputation fears are dramatically overinflated in our minds.
    

• Mind the Gap
  
  • Before making your next significant decision, write down what you would choose if no one would ever know about it and you'd never have to explain it. Then write down what you're inclined to choose when considering how it will be perceived. If these answers differ, you're being influenced by reputation management rather than authentic judgment. This doesn't mean the reputation-neutral choice is always right, but it reveals when your decision-making is being distorted by concern for approval. 
    

• Lean on Your Foxhole
  
  • Meet with your foxhole regularly to discuss the gap between how you're showing up publicly and how you're feeling internally. Use these relationships as laboratories for practicing authenticity in lower-stakes environments. The more comfortable you become being fully known by a few people, the less you'll need validation from everyone else.
    

True leadership excellence emerges not when you perfect your reputation, but when you release your attachment to it. When you stop spending energy managing others' perceptions and start investing it in genuine contribution, you discover a freedom that transforms both your effectiveness and your experience of leadership. 

Checkout Surrender the Outcome on Amazon and order The Score That Matters with Ryan Hawk & Brook Cupps. The latest blog from Blue Collar Grit can be found here!

​